What are the CONS of an electric water pump?

blumi00GT

Founding Member
Jun 26, 2002
79
0
6
Thuringia, Germany
Hi there!

Almost everyone knows the pros of an electric water pump (that what the ads tell you):
- less drag on the accesory belt
- constant cooling
- high flow even with low RPM (let's say in the waiting line on the drag strip)
- cools everytime when the key is in "ON" position, even when the engine is not running


But what are the cons? There must be something the ads don't tell you, otherwise the cars would came from factory with such a pump.

Are they loud? Do they break twice a year? Do they harm in any way to a daily driver?

Blumi
 
  • Sponsors (?)


If I remember correctly Mezerie told me that the pump has a 2500 hour life expectancy. You can do the math to estimate how many years it will last...

I have used mine for almost two years (1year 10month) and have yet to experience a failure. Being that the mezerie pump uses a brushed DC motor, it will fail!!! When it will fail is the question.

I would like to know when it fails so I designed a current monitoring circuit. If the current goes to low (open circuit) or to high (locked rotor) a led will illuminate.

To sum up my feelings on the Mezerie... Cool
 
If you are wondering about getting an electric water pump... When my Mezerie fails I will replace it with the stock pump and order another Mezerie ($320) :nice:. For $320 you get 8-14 lb/ft tq from idle to redline and it will last for 2-5 (or more) years depending on how many hours you drive the car. FYI I have had the Mezerie for 32K miles. It is really free HP & TQ, the alternator provides a fairly steady current flow to the pump, and the extra load the alternator puts on the engine is distributed over time. So the load on the engine is always the same at any RPM but the mechanical pump consumes more engine power as RPMs increase. It is a simple concept that works well and is more efficient than the original (mechanical) design. But, a brushed DC motor will eventually fail, that is a fact :( . Make your own decision but atleat you have some facts.

:cheers: :cheers: :cheers:
 
YtnGT said:
If you are wondering about getting an electric water pump... When my Mezerie fails I will replace it with the stock pump and order another Mezerie ($320) :nice:. For $320 you get 8-14 lb/ft tq from idle to redline and it will last for 2-5 (or more) years depending on how many hours you drive the car. FYI I have had the Mezerie for 32K miles. It is really free HP & TQ, the alternator provides a fairly steady current flow to the pump, and the extra load the alternator puts on the engine is distributed over time. So the load on the engine is always the same at any RPM but the mechanical pump consumes more engine power as RPMs increase. It is a simple concept that works well and is more efficient than the original (mechanical) design. But, a brushed DC motor will eventually fail, that is a fact :( . Make your own decision but atleat you have some facts.

:cheers: :cheers: :cheers:

So, quick question. Did you notice better cooling with the meziere?
 
The pump receives power through relay contacts. You have to install a single pole relay that closes when the ignition key is ON. The install is simple as long as you can follow directions. Connect a switched hot wire from the wiring harness to one side of the relay coil and the other side to ground. One side of the relay contact is wired to the battery (fused of course) and the other goes to the + pump wire. The pump - wire is grounded.
 
So where can you find a switched 12 volt that turns on when the fan engages? If oyu wire it that way the pump is always running. And if the T-stat is closed then the pump can't circulate the water.
 
lopey4.6 said:
So where can you find a switched 12 volt that turns on when the fan engages? If oyu wire it that way the pump is always running. And if the T-stat is closed then the pump can't circulate the water.

I don't think you would need that just for the fact that the stock water pump is always running, no matter what. I don't know much about the cooling system of the modular motors, but I assume there is a sort of heater bypass that allows coolant to flow through the heater core at all times. :shrug: