GusinCA said:
I have heard, however, that the lowest fuel grade often doesn't have the cleaning agents that the plus and super fuels have, is this true?
I have two Fords, a 2000 GT vert, and a 2004 Expedition. I have heard both of them knock slightly under hard loads (acceleration or trailer pulling) so I use 89, this has solved the issue permanently.
As you car ages it can increase compression ratios so that the next grade may need to be used. Really all cars are different and all engine wear is different. If you car starts out with 87, but over time it builds up carbon which increases compression and the 89 may be needed, but as it ages it will wear parts and lower compression which in the end may end up back at 87.
Remember also the Octane Rating is based on the Research and Motor Methods. R +/- M. It is an average of both. There is usally an 8 point gap between them. To get 87 octane, they will take a research method and come up 91 Octane while the motor method will show 83 octane. Just add 4 points for the Research Rating and minus 4 for the motor method.
As for cleaning agents i find that to be a load of crap. Gasoline distilled from crude oil has a very low octane rating. Its octane rating can be increase by adding chemical agents. Back when lead was used it was a cheap and easy way to increase octane yet keep price down. Now they use a whole bunch of chemicals such as tertiary butyl alcohol. I don't see anyone adding lead into their engines today. So to say 87 is dirty over 93 doesn't make sense since they come from the same source yet one has more added octane increasers over the other.
I also don't see how gasoline, which is very corrosive could be a cleaning agent inside the engine. It doesn't have anytime to dissolve anything within the engine. I don't know many solevents that work instantly and most need to soke for a while.
If you put your car under a heavy load, such as towing, you may need to increase the octane just to protect it. A engine under towing conditions is usally an engine working at or near its peak. Drag racing works an engine at or near its peak. If you go to the track its sometime worthwhile to increase octane to protect your engine at the sametime possibly lowering performance. Some engines work better due to higher octane, but a jump from 87 to 93 won't help at all. While an 87 to 89 could without a cut in perfomance. Also note that many cars have high and low octane table to account for the different fuels. My GTO can run fine on 87 octane with a higher chance of preignition even though it recommends 91 octane. The car is able to switch between the table to get the best run from then engine. Its not instantaneous as the car learns and responds to whats going on, but in the end i will lose performance because its a lower octane then the optimal settings recommends.
Only use higher octane when needed or required, otherwise your possibly lowering performance and wasting money. In my case i don't have 91 octane in my area and i can only get 87,89,93 so i get 93 because my car recommends 91.