Chris...
Well, this seems a bit of a mystery regarding the finish of the wheels.
Let me say first, that I have only seen a "silver painted" version of this wheel. That was what had me asking you about them in the first place, after seeing yours. Furthermore, it seems that an equal number of retailers of this wheel list it as being painted, opposed to those that list it as a polished wheel. In fact, the older (saved) link I'd been using to the AR website (which took me to the same catalog page your link did), states the wheel style A69 as a 1-piece painted/machined alloy....
http://www.americanracing.com/wheel...sc=1-piece painted / machined alloy§ion=V
Yet, your link directs you to a similar page stating that it IS polished. Hmmm...
So, it would seem, that either AR has two versions of this wheel now, or they have made a change somewhere along the line since it's introduction? Interesting too, is that in a search of sites pertaining to the Ansen Sprint wheel, I found another earlier webpage with AR's media release of the wheel's reintroduction to the market. (can't find it again now..figures)
But, it stated the wheel as being fully poished as well.
So, perhaps a call or email to them might be something I will have to do. Although I would purchase the wheel either way, I'd prefer it polished as opposed to painted if possible, or available.
Lastly, wouldn't the correct order number actually be A69-5734... with the 4-41/4 bolt pattern?