First off, DO NOT USE PAINT THINNER!!!!!!!!!! It will make the biggest disastrous mess you have ever seen. Plastic + thinner = melts the plastic/smears ... just not good.
Whenever you wiped it down with rubbing alcohol, did it dry? That stuff dries really quickly, so unless you wiped it down then IMMEDIATELY sprayed it, I doubt that's the problem. One thing, just as a FWIW, anything that you paint you should always scuff it first. So like before you wiped it down with rubbing alcohol, take a scotchbrite pad and scuff it up real good. That will allow the paint to adhere to the surface.
I'm gonna try to help you out and give you probably more info than you need ...... Ok, so you want to re-spray it when it's not humid or when it is the least humid time of the day. If you sprayed it when it was raining, if so, that's what caused it. I know what you mean about humidity, around here it's ridiculous too. I painted my trunk recently, at home, and had to figure out the hard way on many things. I know that is on a much larger scale but I know you want your pillar look good. So what I did was went to
www.wunderground.com and used that weather site to get my predicted humidity for the day. It tells you like 6 or so times of day and the projected humidity. That's how I judged when to spray. I know thats a lot of info for something small but I thought it may help.
You should take it inside and let it dry good (not humid). After that, get a scotchbrite pad and just scuff it up. If nothing strange happens (like huge chunks of paint peel off or something) then proceed. Wipe it down with rubbing alcohol. Use paper towels. Get two and use one to wipe it on and the other to wipe it dry, know what I'm sayin? Then use a tack rag (blue one, like a dollar from an autoparts store) if you want. This removes the small dust particles that can cause fisheyes. But if you don't want to do this then it ain't the end of the world.
Find a time where the humidity is 80 percent or less and then re-spray it. It should work out fine ya do it like that. If you got any other questions, post em. Good luck and if you get frustrated, quit for a while and come back to it.
I just read that you are using bumper paint. That stuff dries relatively dull .. post a bigger pic if you can. Because you may just need to clear it.