Funny,
Weathertech floor mats were actually the very first thing I put in my car when I got it. I made the mistake of going with their cheaper set, the ones that aren't laser scanned/matched to the specific car, and they promptly went back the next day. The cheaper ones are very thick, unsecured, they flop around like crazy and the bottoms of my shoes were constantly catching up on them causing them to curl.
The digital fit floorliners however, have been a dream. Perfect fit, rugged, clean appearance and perfect function. You can take them out and hit them with a hose and a paper towel and be done with them in a second.
Another thing that mattered to me, the big red WeatherTech emblem can easily be peeled off clean. I hate excess labels on everything and I think it looks much much cleaner without them.