Cold Air Intakes

mpeach1976

Active Member
Feb 14, 2014
141
21
39
Are CAIs worth buying or just hype and good looks? I'm guessing the latter, but I keep getting mixed answers when researching online. I am under the impression that the ones that do work are the kits that are "tune required" in which case the tune would be supporting most of the power adding gain? I'm a total layman on these and overall want to know: Are they worth buying or a waste? Thanks in advance.
 
  • Sponsors (?)


In general, aftermarket CAIs for the S197s don't really get you much outside of looks and some sound. It is generally accepted that most, if not all, of the power gains are from the tune. I haven't heard of anyone really getting any significant gains from an intake that doesn't require a tune.

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
 
In general, aftermarket CAIs for the S197s don't really get you much outside of looks and some sound. It is generally accepted that most, if not all, of the power gains are from the tune. I haven't heard of anyone really getting any significant gains from an intake that doesn't require a tune.

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Unfortunately this is what I have also deduced. Basically to add power to my car within the constraints of California emissions... It's all about top end intake and cat back exhaust.
 
Ah California. Yes it's a difficult state for car enthusiasts. You can also look at different intake manifolds but you would still require a tune and wouldn't really see the benefit until high rpms. Is forced induction not allowed (I'm not familiar with all the regulations there)? You might have to consult with vendors, but I'm pretty sure I've seen people running centri's with stock exhaust manifolds and mid pipe.

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
 
Ah California. Yes it's a difficult state for car enthusiasts. You can also look at different intake manifolds but you would still require a tune and wouldn't really see the benefit until high rpms. Is forced induction not allowed (I'm not familiar with all the regulations there)? You might have to consult with vendors, but I'm pretty sure I've seen people running centri's with stock exhaust manifolds and mid pipe.

Sent from my Nexus 6 using Tapatalk
Yeah you can go forced induction here whether it be root/twinscrew or centrifugal. You can only open your motor up as much as is California compliant, but you can still make pretty decent power in California.
 
Are CAIs worth buying or just hype and good looks? I'm guessing the latter, but I keep getting mixed answers when researching online. I am under the impression that the ones that do work are the kits that are "tune required" in which case the tune would be supporting most of the power adding gain? I'm a total layman on these and overall want to know: Are they worth buying or a waste? Thanks in advance.
The CAI and tune work hand in hand and make a big difference IMHO. Really woke up my 2012 GT and it's a good bang for the buck investment.
 
You get American Muscle catalogs? If not go to their web site. The ads were claiming up to 37 HP with my set up. Never had it on a dyno but it made a helluva difference....like taking your foot off the brake!
Yes I get a catalog from them, and I go online and check their stuff out. I was looking at a K&N and CAI kit that they sell with the Bama tuner. That will probably be my next purchase. My goal is to gain as much horsepower as I can, while staying naturally aspirated. I was talking to the guys at Galpin auto sports and they said installing a blower would cost me in the ballpark of 10,000 and that would yield a gain of 140 hp. 140 hp sounds good, but if I could hit 100 while doing it myself, staying naturally aspirated, and for a fraction of that price that is much more worth it to me. I think that 420 horse engine is a great starting point. I just think that $10,000 for 140 hp doesn't really add up.
 
Yes I get a catalog from them, and I go online and check their stuff out. I was looking at a K&N and CAI kit that they sell with the Bama tuner. That will probably be my next purchase. My goal is to gain as much horsepower as I can, while staying naturally aspirated. I was talking to the guys at Galpin auto sports and they said installing a blower would cost me in the ballpark of 10,000 and that would yield a gain of 140 hp. 140 hp sounds good, but if I could hit 100 while doing it myself, staying naturally aspirated, and for a fraction of that price that is much more worth it to me. I think that 420 horse engine is a great starting point. I just think that $10,000 for 140 hp doesn't really add up.
After the CAI / tune the next step would be headers and mid pipe. Now we're talking some money and maybe 25-30 HP gain. Those pipes will improve the gain on any other performance mods you make though. I've considered a super charger or blower myself but then you'll have to replace many supporting components along with it. Drive shaft, clutch....the list goes on.
 
Are CAIs worth buying or just hype and good looks? I'm guessing the latter, but I keep getting mixed answers when researching online. I am under the impression that the ones that do work are the kits that are "tune required" in which case the tune would be supporting most of the power adding gain? I'm a total layman on these and overall want to know: Are they worth buying or a waste? Thanks in advance.
From what I experience the CAI mainly just adds noise. I notice some extra power on hills but on straighaways the factory airbox seemed quicker. I like the noise so have a modified Airaid CAI currently installed. I get most of my speed from the SCT tuner I purchased. I use the Steeda CAI tune option which helps out with the CAI I have. I've compared and when I don't have the Steeda CAI selected, the car is a bit slower. If I knew this I wouldn't have forked out the $300 I spent on it but is what it is. The noise is nice.
 
Hey guys. I just posted in the Welcome Wagon, as I'm brand new to this site.. but I was interested in reading what you all posted because my Airaid intake arrives today and I'm super excited, but I know I'm not going to feel much of a difference until I get that tuner (Bama is what hubs and I think we want to get.. any suggestions?). I already have a magnaflow axle back exhaust that i put on last year this time, so I love the sound but seeing as it's an S197 it still doesn't exactly have the kick that I know it can ;)

(I have a 2014 charcoal grey v6)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Hey guys. I just posted in the Welcome Wagon, as I'm brand new to this site.. but I was interested in reading what you all posted because my Airaid intake arrives today and I'm super excited, but I know I'm not going to feel much of a difference until I get that tuner (Bama is what hubs and I think we want to get.. any suggestions?). I already have a magnaflow axle back exhaust that i put on last year this time, so I love the sound but seeing as it's an S197 it still doesn't exactly have the kick that I know it can ;)

(I have a 2014 charcoal grey v6)

For your mods, a tune from any one of the common names should be fine (including Bama). As you noted, the axle back and CAI are pretty much just for sound. The real gains come from the tune so I'm sure you'll notice a nice improvement.

FYI, it is usually better if you post new questions as a separate thread so that you get more direct responses. Welcome to the forums! :nice:
 
FYI skyline247, it's actually better to select the search forums link above and post your questions there before submitting any new or additional threads that concern the same topic which has previously been submitted in this forum time and time again.. That being said, if you really expect to get more direct responses, the last thing is by submitting yet another thread about the same topic which has already been brought up and covered..
 
Last edited: