Okay, I might as well join in.
First of all, my beaters and everyday rides use 10w30 quakersludge (cause its cheap or free at work)
They say "people who know use Valvoline" I dunno.
I was always a castrol guy, but my mom had a car for 150,000 miles that I did all of the regular sevice on. Every 3,000. When at 135,000, I pulled the valve cover to replace the gasket, It was seme-clean, but had more sludge than I would have liked to have seen. No more castrol for me.
I have heard if there is a place for a leak, synthetic will find it.
My step dad had an 86 F-150 w/351w, since new. It ran 230,000 hard miles, pulling a 25ft enclosed trailer and still runs, we just sold it. I never had a valve cover off or anything! Here's the kicker, dear old dad did his own service. When I asked him about his service habits, around 200,000 miles he said "I use 15w40 Shell rotella-T, year round, and change the filter every other oil change" The cheap ass, only did the filter every other time for 230,000 miles!!!!!!