I posted pics over on AM's forums and called them this morning. They gave me the option of another set but I declined and asked for store credit instead. They are going to just refund my money which will more than likely go back to them anyway if I decide to buy a cat-back next week.
Randy S. hooked me up with a set of OE headlights for $79.99 each.
So there ya go, mustangtuning still has great CS and Randy S has the hook-up.