He is right. When I went to buy mine, it had an Idaho Repaired Vehicle title so of course I ran one. Turns out the passenger rear where there are some scrapes and a tail light was busted was where the guy got rear ended at about 20mph. Since the car was so old the insurance company considered it totaled. He bought it back from the insurance company for like $25 and had to get a repaired vehicle title. So carfax isn't always reliable, but a source you want to use. Sorry off tpoic, I know.