I feel like a 265 on a 18x9 is almost perfectly square, but isnt a 275 around the limit you wanna put on a 9 inch wheel? On a different note, there is a kid with an Audi that lives in my neighborhood, lowered to hell, he was rolling his fenders (well attempting to) with an ice scraper the other day, and he runs a 215 on a 9.5" wide wheel! Now that looks like ****!
Well I was running Nitto 555's and Nittos run a little small from what I'm told. However, compared to the 265 BF's that were on the front before, they looked 100x's better.