Ah ha! A controversy now!. Apparently it does matter, at least that's what the guys a Classic Auto Air claim. I'm not inclined to believe that having the water control valve on one side or the other matters when it comes to the fact that my vent temp is 60 degrees. But I thought I'd try it. I'm leaning to the notion that their valve sucks and doesn't really shut flow off completly. But that's just my ignorant opinion.