Spoiler or no Spoiler...?

I think it looks naked without a spoiler.

Each to his own. Your car, your money, do what you want. I'll be going without. I just think it looks better that way.

Huh?

Nice post, rhumbline!

I never said they were ricey, but they are along the same lines - for looks primarily - no function!

And as far as 'mature', I didn't mean it in the sense that you think - I simply meant that this design is very well done and developed much further than its predecessor(s), and can stand alone without stylistic garbage propping it up. And I already have the family sedan('03 330i 6-spd).

Ok, you can have the spoiler - just no fake scoops...

It's a matter of taste and a person's sense of what "style" is. How many out-of-shape guys do you see that plaster tattoos all over their arms, and wear sunglasses 24-7, just to look tough, with the excuse "if I'm going to BE tough I gotta LOOK tough", and they look in the mirror each day and think they are God's gift to style, and imposing looking. Yeah, sure, whatever Then there's the one guy in the bar who has no tattoos, doesn't feel the NEED for any because he's comfortable in his own skin, wears unassuming clothes, but you can tell he's packing alot of power, and could rip the head off of any of those tatty posers at the drop of a hat. But he's cool and confident, he has no need to advertise and be a flake. I think that scenario often is a good analogy to car styling. There's a fine line with styling accessories, where you stop looking tough, and you start to look like a flippin poser, horendously insecure, starving for attention and looks, dressed for a gunfight but only prepared for a slap-fight. That's the illness of the ricer, slapping spoilers and scoops and ground effects on the car in the hopes that the IMAGE detracts people away from the fact that he's piloting his mom's ex-grocery-getter Honda that was handed down to him 'cause that's all he could afford insurance on. That's why when I see all the cries for more boy-racer stuff to be attached to what is just a 300 h.p. GT, that will be sedate compared to the higher performance models yet to come, and realize that I'm gonna see alot of '05 GT's out there, aftermarket spoilered and scooped to the hilt, and looking damn cheesy as they get boinked by a 4-door Subaru with an adjustable wastegate. Not that the rear spoiler is over the line on the GT, it's not. But I think it's wrong to think those of us who DON'T want the spoiler are family sedan type drivers. No no no, you totally misunderstand. We just don't feel the need to have our car be a rolling equivalent to a puffed-out birdchest.

I'm still undecided, but the wingless does rock. Hope this helps some of you.

Excellent post, and a great analogy. My sentiments exactly! Got to watch out for those quiet types - I guess that's why I have always liked the 'sleeper' approach to car building.

definitely with spoiler.

While I personally think spoilers are up to the individual. I think the argument of them adding weight. Is just a little on the obsessive side. I took mine off. And it was light enough that I doubt it adds enough weight to the car. To throw off any kind of performance. Drag on the other hand may be a different argument.
I would rather not have the spoiler. Simply because it doesn't look like it belongs on the 05. I will be putting a ducktail spoiler on it.

The spoiler is useless and breaks up the clean lines of the car. Go without!

I like both ways- with or without

Without i think you would get a look like this !!

http://www.cardomain.com/memberpage/218294

[66 Fastback- Also would love to have Rims too from Pic !!

No spoiler looks good to me. It lets the lines of the car flow by themselves.