I think there may be some misleading info here. the op doesnt give much info either. If you CANNOT tilt your rocker or push the pushrod down by hand and have the plunger go down, given that your lifter is NOT filled with oil and both valves are in the CLOSED position, then you have adjusted your valve train wrong and your gonna be holding open valves. Im pretty sure this guy means the pplunger on the top of the lifter. not the whole lifter itself. I think the guys lifters are fine. Do you have roller rockers? what are your mods. is the car stock?