I agree with many of you that the '05 wheels look out of place. To me, they look like they belong on the F-150 or the Explorer. There's simply too much spoke surface on the wheels, and it's very apparent with the chromed version.
My feel is if you're going with the retro-1967 look for the entire car, why not have the Bullitt wheels as an option (as it is very common to see a '67, '68, etc. with the Torq Thrust wheels on 'em).
Shoot, my 2003 had three different wheel options to choose from. 1. Standard 5-spoke 17" Painted Alloy, 2. 17" Premium Alloy (Bullitt's), and 3. 17" 5-spoke Bright (basically polished versions of the '99-'02 Cobra's).