This is a tough decision--they put a ton of great parts on the car and give it back with new stuff. I just don't like the work they do. I know it is done in a week, the problem I have is it looks like it was done in a week. If they did it to my car I feel I would have to rip the car apart and redo the entire car because of quality concerns. I often wonder how many of those cars don't make it home except on a wrecker? Every time I have watched the show there is no mention of test drives, front end alignments, charging A/C, etc. It is always a last minute, he'll be here in 20 minutes, we can't get the engine to fire. What else doesn't work? I definitely would repaint as the "Foose" look doesn't make my hood go up and down.
Bottom line--while I would love all the new parts on my Mustang, I have instructed my wife to keep Overhaulin away from what's in my garage. On the other hand, my beater 86 F150 4x4 sits in the driveway.....