Mike you aren't gonna win dude. Haters will hate - do your own thing. I'll pop mine depending on the mood.
Sometimes with my girlfriend, when we are, uhhh.....about to uhhh....yeah.
She'll flip it up because she says I look 'sexy'. If I'm getting laid because my collar is popped then so be it.
****, I won't even go into detail about how I used to wear TWO polos at the same time and popped the collars. I got tired of the haters so I try not to be too much of a pimp....
And no, I don't own ANY pink, purple or lime green shirts. I own one light yellow (with the blue polo man) because it's my school colors. I usually wear it for homecoming and such.
Joe